Problems and prospects derived from comparative analysis of advantages and limitations in CIS taxation systems to improve RF real estate taxation

Abstract

Economy digitalization calls for an upgrade of all economic processes. The subject of the research in this paper is the RF taxation system, its challenges and possible trajectories of its development defined from the analysis of the national taxation features in post-Soviet countries in the context of the social, economic, and political transformations, as well as from the integration into the global economic space. The analysis of the CIS national taxation systems is advantageous as the countries share national economic systems, political regimes, management systems, economy structures, population mindsets, and borders. The purpose of the research is to explore the taxable incomes to define the real estate taxes in CIS countries to detect the problems and key advantages in the national taxation systems, and this can identify promising areas in improving the RF real estate taxation. Development and justification of possible areas for the RF taxation system improvement, which satisfy the requirements of all subjects of the RF taxation system and provide the better quality of the taxation management, more precise taxable income, decrease the inequality in distributing the tax burden among the tax payers. Substantial results of the research which underlie its novelty are as follows: 1) taxable income features with regard to the national legislative documents which regulate the CIS property taxation are analyzed to calculate the real estate taxes; 2) three main approaches to find the taxable property income (examination of cadastral or other types of public evaluation, reference to the average annual or residual value of real estate, reference to the real estate area) were found; 3) key drawbacks in the acting RF taxation system are grouped; 4) key areas for upgrading the RF real estate taxation by better quality of information, development and introduction of digital tools for a large scale evaluation of property units, digitalization of cadastral data, having more information in the cadaster are offered. Further research is seen to be connected with a more comprehensive analysis of the rules defining fair cadastral property value to remedy the drawbacks in the present evaluation methodology.

Keywords

real estate tax, land tax, cadastral value, average annual value, CIS taxation system, digitalization, taxation management

For citation

Daineko L.V., Goncharova N.V., Karavaeva N.M., Yurasova I.I. Problems and prospects derived from comparative analysis of advantages and limitations in CIS taxation systems to improve RF real estate taxation. Perm University Herald. Economy, 2021, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 106–126. DOI 10.17072/1994-9960-2021-2-106-126

References

1. Gorskii I.V. Model'nyi Nalogovyi kodeks SNG kak instrument integratsii [CIS model tax code as an instrument of integration]. Finansovyi zhurnal [Financial Journal], 2012, no. 2, pp. 31–36. (In Russian).
2. Klirikov A.G., Moshkova G.N. O nalogooblozhenii gosudarstv-uchastnikov SNG [Taxation in CIS countries]. Ekonomika. Nalogi. Pravo [Economy. Taxation. Law], 2014, no. 4, pp. 123–127. (In Russian).
3. Smirnov V.I. Nalogooblozhenie v stranakh Sodruzhestva Nezavisimykh Gosudarstv [Taxation in the Commonwealth of Independent States]. Obespechenie ekonomicheskoi bezopasnosti Rossii v sovremennykh usloviyakh [Economic Security in Russia in Modern Context], 2018, pp. 389–392. (In Russian).
4. Pilipenko I.V., Pishchik V.Ya., Bunich G.A. Perekhod k rynochnoi ekonomike i strukturnye reformy v gosudarstvakh-chlenakh Evraziiskogo ekonomicheskogo soyuza [Transition to the market economy and structural reforms in members states of the Eurasian Economic Union]. Saint Petersburg, Naukoemkie tekhnologii Publ., 2019. 976 p. (In Russian).
5. Lukashova I.V. Sravnitel'nyi analiz naloga na zhiluyu nedvizhimost' v stranakh Tsentral'noi Azii [Comparative analysis of tax on housing in the Baltic countries]. Finansy i upravlenie [Finance and Management], 2016, no. 2, pp. 1–21. (In Russian). doi: 10.7256/2409-7802.2016.2.17578.
6. Grigorov K.N. Sravnitel'no-pravovoi analiz regulirovaniya nalogov na imushchestvo organizatsii Respubliki Belarus' i Respubliki Kazakhstan [Comparative law analysis of regulation of company’s property taxes in the Republic of Belarus and the Republic of Kazakhstan]. Finansovoe pravo [Financial Law], 2015, no. 5, pp. 31–37. (In Russian).
7. Zozulya V.V., Zhuravlev P.D. Garmonizatsiya nalogovykh sistem kak sposob ogranicheniya nalogovoi konkurentsii v usloviyakh integratsii [Harmonization of tax systems as a method of limitation of tax competition in conditions of integration]. Natsional'nye interesy: prioritety i bezopasnost' [National Interests: Priorities and Security], 2014, no. 23, pp. 33–39. (In Russian).
8. Guseinova G.M. Tendentsii razvitiya nalogovykh i byudzhetnykh sistem stran SNG [Tendencies of tax and budgetary systems development of the CIS countries]. Izvestiya Sankt-Peterburgskogo gosudarstvennogo ekonomicheskogo universiteta [Bulletin of Saint Petersburg State University of Economics], 2009, no. 3, pp. 49–57. (In Russian).
9. Golodova Zh.G., Ranchinskaya Yu.S. Nalogooblozhenie nedvizhimogo imushchestva stran SNG [Taxation of real estate of citizens: Experience of the CIS countries]. Mezhdunarodnyi bukhgalterskii uchet [International Accounting], 2014, no. 37 (331), pp. 11–22. (In Russian).
10. Kuznetsov L.D. Aktual'nost' izucheniya nalogovykh sistem Rossii i zarubezhnykh stran [Relevance of studying the tax systems of Russia and foreign countries]. Yuridicheskaya nauka [Legal Science], 2020, no. 10, pp. 125–128. (In Russian).
11. Kosenkova Yu.Yu. Zarubezhnyi opyt nalogooblozheniya nedvizhimosti [Foreign practices of real estate taxation]. Sotsial'no-ekonomicheskie yavleniya i protsessy [Social-Economic Phenomena and Processes], 2014, vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 61–64. (In Russian).
12. Simakova E.K. Pravovoi rezhim naloga na imushchestvo fizicheskikh lits: rossiiskii i zarubezhnyi opyt [Legal regime of natural person’s property taxation mode: Russian and foreign experience]. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskoi yuridicheskoi akademii [Vestnik of Saint Petersburg Juridical Academy], 2016, no. 2, pp. 78–83. (In Russian).
13. Adigamova F.F., Orlova M.E. Puti garmonizatsii nalogovogo regulirovaniya v stranakh SNG i EAES [Ways of harmonization of tax regulation in the CIS and EAEU countries]. Vestnik ekonomiki, prava i sotsiologii [The Review of Economy, the Law and Sociology], 2019, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 6–12. (In Russian).
14. Ziyadullaev N.S., Ziyadullaev U.S. 25 let SNG i evraziiskie integratsionnye proekty: ozhidaniya, razocharovaniya i perspektivy [25 years of CIS and Eurasian integration projects: expectations, disappointments and perspectives]. Ekonomicheskaya nauka sovremennoi Rossii [Economics of Contemporary Russia], 2017, no. 2 (77), pp. 123–136. (In Russian).
15. Valiev D.S., Khabarova I.A. Istoriya razvitiya gosudarstvennogo kadastrovogo ucheta [History of state cadastral registration development]. Mezhdunarodnyi zhurnal prikladnykh nauk i tekhnologii «Integral» [International Journal of Applied Sciences and technologies “Integral”], 2018, no. 4, pp. 20–32. (In Russian).
16. Akhmedov M.M. Problemy sovershenstvovaniya mekhanizmov primeneniya naloga na nedvizhimost' v Azerbaidzhane [Improvement problems the mechanism of taxation of real estate in Azerbaijan]. Ekonomika i biznes: teoriya i praktika [Economy and Business: Theory and Practice], 2016, no. 2, pp. 20–25. (In Russian).
17. Margaryan R.A. Problemy i perspektivy imushchestvennogo nalogooblozheniya v Respublike Armeniya [Problems and future of the real estate taxation in the Republic of Armenia]. Nalogi i nalogooblozhenie [Taxes and Taxation], 2019, no. 1, pp. 1–6. (In Russian). doi: 10.7256/2454-065X.2019.1.28721.
18. Tul'ko V.A. Problemy i perspektivy razvitiya naloga na nedvizhimost' v Respublike Belarus' [Problems and future development of real estate taxation in the Republic of Belarus]. NIRS BGEU: sbornik nauchnykh statei [Scientific Resource of Belarus State University of Economics: Collection of Works], 2019, iss. 8, pp. 157–159. (In Russian).
19. Ishchuk T.L., Baimukhametova A.S. Osobennosti nalogooblozheniya fizicheskikh lits s imushchestva i prochikh dokhodov v Rossii i Kazakhstane [Features of taxation of individuals from property and other income in Russia and Kazakhstan]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ekonomika [Tomsk State University Journal of Economics], 2018, no. 42, pp. 139–160. (In Russian). doi: 10.17223/19988648/42/10.
20. Tazhikhanov A. Nalogooblozhenie nedvizhimosti Respubliki Kazakhstan [Taxation of real estate in the Republic of Kazakhstan]. Sovremennye innovatsii [Modern Innovations], 2017, no. 4 (18), pp. 24–27. (In Russian).
21. Lukashova I.V. Sravnitel'nyi analiz fiskal'noi effektivnosti deistvuyushchego naloga na zhiluyu nedvizhimost' i nalogovykh initsiativ v Kirgizskoi Respublike [Comparative analysis of fiscal efficiency for the acting real estate tax and tax initiatives in the Kyrgyz Republic]. Nalogi i nalogooblozhenie [Taxes and Taxation], 2018, no. 2, pp. 33–44. (In Russian). doi: 10.7256/2454-065X.2018.2.25439.
22. Rysalieva M.Sh. Perspektivy razvitiya imushchestvennogo nalogooblozheniya v Kyrgyzskoi Respublike [Prospects for the development of property taxation in the Kyrgyz Republic]. Evraziiskoe Nauchnoe Ob"edinenie [Eurasian Scientific Association], 2020, no. 2 (3), pp. 193–196. (In Russian).
23. Rysalieva M.Sh. O roli zemel'nogo naloga v formirovanii dokhodov gosudarstvennogo byudzheta Kyrgyzskoi Respubliki [On the role of land tax in the formation of gains of the state budget in Kyrgyz Republic]. Mezhdunarodnyi nauchno-issledovatel'skii zhurnal [International Research Journal], 2020, no. 2-2 (92), pp. 122–125. (In Russian). doi: 10.23670/IRJ.2020.92.2.057.
24. Baranova L.G., Fedorova V.S. Ekonomicheskie posledstviya izmenenii imushchestvennogo nalogooblozheniya na makro i mikrourovne [Economic consequences of changes in property taxation at the macro and micro levels]. Ekonomicheskie issledovaniya i razrabotki [Economic Development Research Journal], 2020, no. 5, pp. 7–12. (In Russian).
25. Buzu O.V., Gutsu V.G., Gutsu D.V. Kadastr nedvizhimogo imushchestva v Respublike Moldova: Opyt mezhdistsiplinarnogo issledovaniya. Monografiya [Estate property cadaster in the Republic of Moldova: A case of interdisciplinary research. Monograph]. Kishinev, CEP USM Publ., 2016. 154 p. (In Russian).
26. Buzu O. Sovershenstvovanie organizatsii otsenki nedvizhimogo imushchestva v tselyakh nalogooblozheniya v Respublike Moldova [Better organization of real estate evaluation for taxation purposes in the Republic of Moldova]. Economic Growth in Conditions of Globalization, 2016, pp. 119–122. (In Russian).
27. Zhukova D.Yu. Budushchee naloga na nedvizhimost' [Future real estate taxation]. Teoriya i praktika bukhgalterskogo ucheta i nalogooblozheniya [Theory and Practice of Accounting and Taxation], 2016, pp. 74–80. (In Russian).
28. Turbina N.M. Problemy kadastrovoi otsenki pri vzimanii imushchestvennykh nalogov [Cadastral evaluation problems for property tax collection]. Aktual'nye voprosy sovershenstvovaniya bukhgalterskogo ucheta, statistiki i nalogooblozheniya organizatsii. Materialy VIII mezhdunarodnoi nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii: v 2 tomakh. Tambov, 15 fevralya 2019 g. [Relevant issues of better accounting, statistics, and taxation of organizations. Proceedings from VIII International Scientific Practical Conference: In 2 volumes. Tambov, 15 February 2019]. Tambov, Izdatel'skii dom «Derzhavinskii» Publ., 2019, vol. 2, pp. 58–64. (In Russian).
29. Kudanov R.T. Perspektivy vvedeniya edinogo naloga na nedvizhimoe imushchestvo v Rossii [Future possible introduction of common real estate tax in Russia]. Aktual'nye problemy pravovogo, sotsial'nogo i politicheskogo razvitiya Rossii. Materialy XI Mezhdunarodnoi nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii studentov, magistrantov, aspirantov, soiskatelei: sbornik nauchnykh statei. Saratov, 26 aprelya 2018 g. [Relevant issues of law, social, and political development in Russia. Proceedings from XI International Scientific Practical Conference among students, Master’s degree students, Postgraduates: Collection of scientific papers. Saratov, 26 April 2018]. Saratov, «Saratovskii istochnik» Publ., 2018, pp. 136–138. (In Russian).
30. Vylkova E.S. Napravleniya sovershenstvovaniya imushchestvennogo nalogooblozheniya v Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Improving the property taxation in the Russian Federation]. Ekonomika. Nalogi. Pravo [Economy. Taxation. Law], 2019, no. 12 (1), pp. 127–135. (In Russian). doi: 10.26794/1999-849X-2019-12-1-127-135.
31. Korostelev S.P. Kontseptual'nye problemy nalogooblozheniya nedvizhimosti v Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Conceptual problems of property taxation in the Russian Federation]. Imushchestvennye otnosheniya v Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Property Relations in the Russian Federation], 2017, no. 7 (190), pp. 58–69. (In Russian).
32. Gribovskii S.V. K voprosu o kachestve kadastrovoi otsenki ob"ektov nedvizhimosti dlya tselei nalogooblozheniya [On the question about the quality of cadastral evaluation of the property units for taxation purposes]. Imushchestvennye otnosheniya v Rossiiskoi Federatsii [Property Relations in the Russian Federation], 2019, no. 9 (216), pp. 24–29. (In Russian).
33. Shishkina V.A., Khusht N.I. Prakticheskii opyt edinogo nalogooblozheniya nedvizhimosti [Practical experience of unified real estate taxation]. Elektronnyi setevoi politematicheskii zhurnal «Nauchnye trudy KubGTU» [Scientific Works of the Kuban State Technological University], 2020, no. 6, pp. 121–129. Available at: http://ntk.kubstu.ru/file/3079 (accessed 12.02.2021).
34. Dzhuraeva G.A. Nalogooblozhenie v Respublike Tadzhikistan: problemy i perspektivy [Taxation in the Republic of Tajikistan: Problems and prospects]. Vestnik Rossiisko-Tadzhikskogo (Slavyanskogo) universiteta [Bulletin of Russian-Tajik Slavonic University], 2018, no. 2, pp. 160–167. (In Russian).
35. Blinichkina N.Yu. Nalogovaya politika respubliki Tadzhikistan v rakurse ekonomicheskoi bezopasnosti: oshibki i perspektivy [Tax policy of the Republic of Tajikistan in the foreshortening of economic security: Errors and prospects]. Fundamental'nye i prikladnye issledovaniya v sovremennom mire [Fundamental and Applied Studies in Modern World], 2018, no. 23, pp. 133–137. (In Russian).
36. Ma"murov A.M., Nomanova A.S. Tendentsii razvitiya nalogovogo administrirovaniya v Tadzhikistane [Tendencies of development in reference to tax administering in Tajikistan]. Vestnik Tadzhikskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta prava, biznesa i politiki. Seriya obshchestvennykh nauk [Bulletin of TSULBP. Series of Social Sciences], 2014, no. 1, pp. 144–151. (In Russian).
37. Khamidova S.Kh. Rol' nalogovoi sistemy Respubliki Tadzhikistan v strukture natsional'noi ekonomiki [Role of tax system of the Republic of Tajikistan in the structure of the national economy]. Vestnik Tadzhikskogo natsional'nogo universiteta. Seriya sotsial'no-ekonomicheskikh i obshchestvennykh nauk [Bulletin of Tajik National University. Series of Economic and Social Sciences], 2019, no. 5-2, pp. 20–26. (In Russian).
38. Nazhmiddinov M.M., Nadezhdina S.D. K voprosu ob effektivnosti nalogovoi sistemy Respubliki Tadzhikistan [On the efficiency of the taxation system in the Republic of Tajikistan]. Aktual'nye napravleniya nauchnoi mysli: problemy i perspektivy. Sbornik materialov VI Vserossiiskoi nauchno-prakticheskoi (natsional'noi) konferentsii. Novosibirsk, 18–20 marta 2019 g. [Relevant Areas in Scientific Thought: Problems and Prospects. Collection of Materials from VI Russian Scientific Practical (National) Conference. Novosibirsk, 18–20 March 2019]. Novosibirsk, Novosibirskii gosudarstvennyi universitet ekonomiki i upravleniya "NINKh" Publ., 2019, pp. 303–312. (In Russian).
39. Dzhumabaev Kh.K. Nekotorye aspekty sovershenstvovaniya nalogovoi sistemy Respubliki Tadzhikistan v usloviyakh rynochnoi ekonomiki [Some aspects of improving the taxation system in the Republic of Tajikistan in the context of market economy]. Vestnik Tadzhikskogo natsional'nogo universiteta. Seriya sotsial'no-ekonomicheskikh i obshchestvennykh nauk [Bulletin of Tajik National University. Series of Economic and Social Sciences], 2018, no. 6, pp. 123–127. (In Russian).
40. Niyazmetov I., Voronin S., Koraboev B., Ugai D. O puti reformirovaniya naloga na imushchestvo v Respublike Uzbekistan [Ways of property tax reform in the Republic of Uzbekistan]. Obshchestvo i ekonomika [Society and Economics], 2021, no. 3, pp. 30–43. (In Russian).
41. Daineko L.V. Problemy, voznikayushchie pri massovoi kadastrovoi otsenke nedvizhimosti [Mass cadastral evaluation of real estate problems]. Rossiiskie regiony v fokuse peremen. Sbornik dokladov XI Mezhdunarodnoi konferentsii. Ekaterinburg, 17–19 noyabrya 2016 g. V 2-kh tomakh. [XI International Conference “Russian Regions in the Focus of Changes”. Yekaterinburg, 17–19 November 2016. In 2 volumes]. Yekaterinburg, UMTs UPI Publ., 2016, vol. 2. pp. 241–244.
42. Dement'eva M.A., Zakharova A.V., Kirova E.A. Opyt nalogooblozheniya nedvizhimogo imushchestva fizicheskikh lits v zarubezhnykh stranakh i ego primenenie v Rossii [Experience of taxation of real estate of individuals in foreign countries and its application in Russia]. Vestnik universiteta [Vestnik Universiteta], 2019, no. 1, pp. 100–107. (In Russian). doi: 10.26425/1816-4277-2019-1-100-107.

Show full text